Skip to main content

Not Just One Way to Play

One of the fascinating things about the banjo is the many ways the instrument is played. For every player, there is seemingly a different method. Some styles have distinct names with many practitioners, whereas other styles are distinctly unique to one musician.

When I first started, I didn't really know another style existed beyond how Earl Scruggs plays, which is a three-finger picking style that involves syncopated "rolls," alternating the thumb, index and middle fingers. Scruggs elevated this style to point that it now bears his name, Scruggs style.

However, Scruggs was not the first to pick the banjo with three fingers, nor was he the first to use metal finger picks, but he was the most popular. Now, his style is emulated by the majority of Bluegrass banjo players. 

Aside from Scruggs style, there were many other finger-picking styles. Old-Time banjoists like Dock Boggs, Charlie Poole, and sometimes Uncle Dave Macon (who played any way he wanted) used three fingers, but usually without metal picks. There were also a number of two-finger styles, either thumb-lead or index-lead, which were used by such players as Roscoe Holcomb, Lee Sexton and Will Keys

Clawhammer is perhaps the second most popular style of playing the banjo, and this is predominantly among Old-Time musicians. Though there are a few clawhammer players who play Bluegrass, most notably Mark Johnson, who calls his style "Clawgrass." 

Clawhammer is basically a two-finger style, only instead of picking upwards with your finger, you strike down with the back of your fingernail and then use the thumb to strike the fifth or another string in the process of bouncing the hand back up for the next down-stroke. In short, you bend your hand into a claw and hammer away. At least, that's how I do it. Here's how John Herrmann does it. 



Many historians believe clawhammer is a variation on the "stroke style" that black-face minstrels used in the mid-1800s. After the Civil War, classical banjo style -- similar to guitar finger-picking -- was popular among ragtime musicians, such as Fred Van Eps and Vess Ossman. In the 1970s, melodic banjo styles became popular among both finger-pickers and clawhammerists, notably Bill Keith and Ken Perlman, respectively.

The banjo can be played in so many ways and can suit any type of music. I haven't even mentioned the styles commonly played on tenor and plectrum banjos, which generally use a pick. Above is just a small sampling of what the banjo can do, and playing styles will continue to evolve as today's musicians incorporate the banjo in various ways. I mean, did you see the Grammys

Comments

  1. Amazing performance and feel. When there's a guitar missing from a jam it usually feels a little thin, but not with this banjo player--it seems like he's overcompensating a little bit to make up for the lack of guitar chords.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I've only recently discovered John Herrmann, but I really love his sound. I wish I could add some of his elements to my playing.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Getting Blitzed with Tom Collins

A little more than a year ago, Salem, Massachusetts-based banjo player and teacher Tom Collins embarked on a yearlong project he called Banjo Blitz. The weekly YouTube series provided short banjo lessons on technique. Each video is about five minutes long, give or take, and presents a short pattern — or “ostinato” — designed to teach and improve a specific aspect of banjo playing.

The mission was to get the audience “to practice clawhammer in discrete chunks every day without the burden of trying to memorize tunes,” Collins says. He wanted to build skills rather than repertoire.

“Let’s take the tune off the table,” says Collins, who has been teaching banjo for 11 years. “Let’s focus on a simple, mantra-like ostinato that can train your body how to execute a technique properly, while training your ears how to hear it properly. Let’s also make it so that you can do this every day without it sucking every spare minute from your life. The big dirty secret about learning how to play an ins…

Clawhammer Picks and You: A Review

Clawhammer picks are a useful tool for increasing volume or to overcome fingernail challenges, such as broken, too short or weak nails. There are all sorts of commercial and homemade solutions available for banjo players, but it can be difficult to decide which options to choose. Thankfully, I've already done some of the work for you.
Just to be clear, I prefer my natural fingernail for frailing. However, there was a time when I experimented with regularly using a pick, and there are instances now where I find that a pick is necessary. Today, I'll take you through the five options I've tried. These are all available online at prices ranging from about $1 to $13.

Reversed/Reshaped Dunlop Pick ($0.75)
This was the most common suggestion before other companies started addressing the gap in the clawhammer pick market. Take a bluegrass pick, flatten it out and wear it backwards. The problem is that it's hard to get the fit right. While Dunlop picks are cheap and readily avai…

Erynn Marshall, Mark Olitsky, Doug Unger: An Old-Time Smorgasbord in Peninsula, Ohio, for Music on the Porches, Sept. 23

Old-time music and banjo fans alike would do well to aim their GPS units toward Peninsula, Ohio, the historic village nestled in the Cuyahoga Valley National Park between Cleveland and Akron. This Saturday is Music on the Porches, which features a number of musical acts playing all around town, starting at 11 a.m. 
The showcase event is Saturday night at the G.A.R. Hall, an evening concert that will feature fiddler Erynn Marshall and multi-instrumentalist Carl Jones, the married old-time duo based in Galax, Virginia; followed by Sean Watkins, formerly of the progressive bluegrass band Nickel Creek; and finally headliner Tim O'Brien, who has recorded with everyone from Steve Martin to Dirk Powell, including the excellent "Songs From the Mountain" album with Powell and John Herrmann (one of my all-time favorites). Doors open at 6:30 p.m., with Marshall and Jones set to start at 7 p.m. Tickets are available online via Eventbrite
But wait, that's not all! 
Marshall wi…