Skip to main content

Banjo Tinkering

There comes a time when you just want something different. Since we all can't own enough banjos to suit our varying tastes from day to day, a fact that our neighbors and loved ones no doubt celebrate, we must instead tinker with our instruments now and again to make new sounds.

My banjo needs a tonal makeover. Right now it is set up with Ome heavy strings, a thin goatskin head and a 5/8-inch bridge of medium weight, all on a 12-inch rim with a Dobson-style tone ring. There is also a swatch of duct tape under the bridge and a wad of plastic grocery bags wrapped with tissue paper stuffed between the head and dowel stick to mute harsh overtones.

Like many old-time banjo players, I'm always in search of the perfect "plunky" sound. However, I've come to the conclusion that stuffing the pot isn't getting the job done. While this practice cuts down on high-pitched brightness, it also kills the warm timbre associated with skin heads. Also, why have a tone ring if you're going to keep it from ringing?

Last night, I was playing around with just muting the strings at the bridge and got some good results. This led me to believe I should either wrap my strings in duct tape a la John Herrmann ...

Or I should get new strings. While I have liked the Ome heavies, I've grown bored of their sound. Today, I put in an order for some Chris Sands heavy strings.

In the past, I've tried various nylon strings, from cheap La Bellas to Aquila Nylguts, but I never found those strings quite to my liking. They always seemed too slack and sounded dull. Way back when we featured Jeff Delfield and his Deep Creek Strings banjos, he suggested trying the Chris Sands strings. They are thicker and higher tension than the previous nylons I've tried, so perhaps they won't be so floppy and dull.

Only time will tell if these strings provide the plunk I'm looking for or if I'm going to have to get a new roll of duct tape.

What's your preferred setup? Do you use steel or nylon strings? Skin or synthetic head? How much duct tape?


  1. I'd trade my first-born (well, almost) for that sound from John Herrmann's banjo. I had seen (and bookmarked) this YouTube video before, but had never noticed the duct tape on the bridge.

  2. I use steel strings because that's what I happen to have several sets of on hand. I did try Aquilla, and liked them. I likely will go back to them when I use up all the steel. My banjo has a 12" head, brass hoop tone ring, Fiberskyn head, Grover bridge and No Knot tailpiece. In the 11 years I've had it, the only thing I've changes is strings and what I stuff in it to play while Mrs. Wanda is sleeping. It takes a LOT of stuffing to keep her asleep! Bubble wrap, tanned possum hide, newspaper, small towel, larger towel. Current stuffing is a small pillow. When I leave the house with it, the stuffing usually stays home. I don't try to change the sound, that's what I fell for when I bought it. And that's what multiple banjos are for. Though finances aren't likely to allow me multiple banjos.


Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Getting Blitzed with Tom Collins

A little more than a year ago, Salem, Massachusetts-based banjo player and teacher Tom Collins embarked on a yearlong project he called Banjo Blitz. The weekly YouTube series provided short banjo lessons on technique. Each video is about five minutes long, give or take, and presents a short pattern — or “ostinato” — designed to teach and improve a specific aspect of banjo playing.

The mission was to get the audience “to practice clawhammer in discrete chunks every day without the burden of trying to memorize tunes,” Collins says. He wanted to build skills rather than repertoire.

“Let’s take the tune off the table,” says Collins, who has been teaching banjo for 11 years. “Let’s focus on a simple, mantra-like ostinato that can train your body how to execute a technique properly, while training your ears how to hear it properly. Let’s also make it so that you can do this every day without it sucking every spare minute from your life. The big dirty secret about learning how to play an ins…

Clawhammer Picks and You: A Review

Clawhammer picks are a useful tool for increasing volume or to overcome fingernail challenges, such as broken, too short or weak nails. There are all sorts of commercial and homemade solutions available for banjo players, but it can be difficult to decide which options to choose. Thankfully, I've already done some of the work for you.
Just to be clear, I prefer my natural fingernail for frailing. However, there was a time when I experimented with regularly using a pick, and there are instances now where I find that a pick is necessary. Today, I'll take you through the five options I've tried. These are all available online at prices ranging from about $1 to $13.

Reversed/Reshaped Dunlop Pick ($0.75)
This was the most common suggestion before other companies started addressing the gap in the clawhammer pick market. Take a bluegrass pick, flatten it out and wear it backwards. The problem is that it's hard to get the fit right. While Dunlop picks are cheap and readily avai…

Erynn Marshall, Mark Olitsky, Doug Unger: An Old-Time Smorgasbord in Peninsula, Ohio, for Music on the Porches, Sept. 23

Old-time music and banjo fans alike would do well to aim their GPS units toward Peninsula, Ohio, the historic village nestled in the Cuyahoga Valley National Park between Cleveland and Akron. This Saturday is Music on the Porches, which features a number of musical acts playing all around town, starting at 11 a.m. 
The showcase event is Saturday night at the G.A.R. Hall, an evening concert that will feature fiddler Erynn Marshall and multi-instrumentalist Carl Jones, the married old-time duo based in Galax, Virginia; followed by Sean Watkins, formerly of the progressive bluegrass band Nickel Creek; and finally headliner Tim O'Brien, who has recorded with everyone from Steve Martin to Dirk Powell, including the excellent "Songs From the Mountain" album with Powell and John Herrmann (one of my all-time favorites). Doors open at 6:30 p.m., with Marshall and Jones set to start at 7 p.m. Tickets are available online via Eventbrite
But wait, that's not all! 
Marshall wi…